Removing a GmbH Managing Director and Terminating the Service Agreement in Germany

German Corporate Lawyers

Removing a GmbH Managing Director and Terminating the Service Agreement in Germany

German Corporate Lawyers

Removing a managing director from a German GmbH is rarely straightforward. One of the most persistent misconceptions in German corporate practice is that removing a managing director from their corporate position automatically ends their employment relationship. It does not — and acting on that assumption can expose a company to significant legal and financial liability.

Under German law, a managing director occupies what is known as a Doppelstellung — a dual legal position. They serve simultaneously as an officer of the company (holding an Organstellung, or corporate organ status) and as a party to a separate civil-law service agreement (Geschäftsführer-Dienstvertrag). These are two entirely distinct legal relationships, and each must be terminated through its own legal process.

Schlun & Elseven advises companies comprehensively on the proper termination of managing director relationships. Our corporate law team combines expertise in preparing shareholders’ resolutions, drafting and terminating managing director service agreements, and managing complex separation processes from start to finish. We develop legally sound strategies that address both corporate and employment law dimensions, ensuring that both legal relationships are brought to an end in a coordinated and legally secure manner. Our lawyers prioritize out-of-court settlements wherever possible. Where litigation becomes unavoidable, we represent clients with a focused and strategically grounded approach.

You are here: Home » German Corporate Lawyers » Removing a Managing Director and Terminating the Service Agreement: Legal Guide for German GmbH Companies

Rated on Google Business

Our Legal Services relating to Removing a GmbH Managing Director in Germany

Legal Advice & Support
  • Review and drafting of managing director service agreements
  • Strategic advice on the removal procedure
  • Preparation and conduct of shareholders’ meetings
  • Drafting legally sound removal resolutions
  • Advice on employment and service law consequences
  • Negotiation of severance and transition arrangements
  • Representation in annulment proceedings and damages claims
Related Legal Services
  • Rights and Duties of a Managing Director
  • Liability of a GmbH Managing Director
  • Shareholders’ Meetings and Resolutions
  • Dissolution and Liquidation of a GmbH

Removal vs. Termination: Two Separate Legal Steps

When a company parts ways with its managing director, two legally independent steps must be taken: the corporate removal (Abberufung) and the termination of the service agreement (Kündigung des Dienstvertrags). These steps are governed by different legal frameworks and must be carefully coordinated in practice to avoid financial exposure and legal uncertainty.

The Corporate Removal (Abberufung)

The removal of a managing director is carried out by a shareholders’ resolution. Under Section 38(1) of the German Limited Liability Companies Act (GmbHG), a GmbH managing director may, in principle, be removed at any time, unless the articles of association restrict this right or make removal contingent on the existence of good cause (wichtiger Grund) under Section 38(2) sentence 1 GmbHG.

Upon removal, the managing director’s corporate officer status (Organstellung) ends immediately, along with their authority to represent and manage the company. The removal takes effect internally without delay; for it to be effective against third parties, it must be registered in the German Commercial Register (Handelsregister).

Termination of the Service Agreement

The managing director’s service agreement is a separate matter entirely. Unlike employees, a GmbH managing director does not hold a standard employment contract. Instead, they are party to a civil-law service agreement governed by Sections 611 et seq. of the German Civil Code (Bürgerliches Gesetzbuch, BGB). This means ordinary employment protection legislation — including the German Dismissal Protection Act (Kündigungsschutzgesetz) — generally does not apply.

Termination of the service agreement is governed primarily by the notice periods stipulated in the contract itself, supplemented by the general provisions of the BGB on service contracts. Summary termination without notice is only permissible where good cause exists that makes continuation of the contractual relationship unreasonable.

Why Both Steps Must Be Taken Together

Problems arise in practice when only one of the two steps is taken. If the managing director is removed without the service agreement being simultaneously terminated, salary and compensation obligations continue to accrue — even though the director is no longer performing any duties. This situation also gives rise to what German law calls Annahmeverzug (creditor’s delay), meaning the company may be liable for remuneration it effectively refused to let the director earn.

Conversely, terminating the service agreement without carrying out the corresponding removal creates its own risks: the managing director formally remains a corporate officer and retains authority to legally bind the company. For this reason, removal and termination of a GmbH managing director’s service agreement should always be planned and implemented together.

The Risks of an Uncoordinated Separation

An uncoordinated separation from a managing director can carry serious legal and financial consequences. Salary obligations continue even where no performance is being rendered. Disputes consume management time and generate legal costs. Legal uncertainty can erode the confidence of business partners, investors, and lenders. Acting early and coordinating both measures avoids these downstream problems.

Schlun & Elseven advises companies on the legally secure removal of managing directors — from the initial consultation through to final settlement. We develop tailored strategies that balance legal requirements with commercial interests. In every case, we assess whether an out-of-court resolution is achievable, as it is typically faster, more cost-effective, and less damaging for both parties.

Prevention: Avoiding Problems Through Careful Contract Drafting

The most effective solution is to prevent these problems from arising in the first place. When entering into a managing director service agreement, companies should proactively identify structural risks and put binding provisions in place — ideally with the assistance of a specialist in German corporate law.

  • Notice periods that are appropriate to the commercial significance of the role
  • Garden leave and release provisions (Freistellung) following termination or removal
  • Severance payment arrangements with objective valuation methods
  • Post-termination non-compete clauses (Wettbewerbsverbote) and associated compensation payments (Karenzentschädigung)
  • Return of company documents and revocation of digital access

Coupling Clauses (Kopplungsklauseln)

Managing director service agreements in Germany frequently include what are known as Kopplungsklauseln — contractual provisions that link the removal of the managing director from their corporate position to the simultaneous termination or terminability of the service agreement. Without such a clause, salary entitlements can continue indefinitely after removal. By contractually coupling removal to the end of the service relationship, this risk can be significantly reduced. However, the clause must be clearly and precisely drafted to be legally effective, which underscores why bespoke contract drafting is essential.

Termination Options in Practice

Mutual Termination Agreement (Aufhebungsvereinbarung)

One of the most practical and flexible mechanisms for ending a managing director relationship is the mutual termination agreement (Aufhebungsvereinbarung). This allows both parties to negotiate a comprehensive settlement of all outstanding matters, including termination date, severance payments, garden leave arrangements, post-termination non-compete obligations, and return of company documents. Depending on the parties’ respective interests, a mutual termination agreement can provide for immediate termination of both legal relationships in exchange for a severance payment, garden leave through to the contractual end date, or staggered severance payments to ease pressure on the company’s liquidity.

Coordinated Ordinary Termination

A particularly practical approach is a coordinated ordinary termination: the shareholders’ removal resolution and the service agreement termination notice are issued simultaneously, with the contractual notice period observed. This can be structured to include simultaneous shareholder resolution and termination notice, garden leave for the duration of the notice period, a severance payment for early termination, and tax-optimized severance structures.

The removal of a managing director and the termination of their service agreement require careful legal coordination. Errors in execution can give rise to ongoing salary obligations, liability exposure, and litigation. Schlun & Elseven advises companies on the legally secure preparation of shareholders’ resolutions, the review and drafting of managing director service agreements, and the implementation of removals, terminations, and mutual termination agreements.

An Overview: Frequently Asked Questions about Removing a GmbH Managing Director

No. Removal ends only the managing director’s corporate officer status. The service agreement must be separately terminated or brought to an end by mutual agreement.

In principle, yes. Under German law, a GmbH managing director can be removed at any time, unless the articles of association restrict this right or make removal contingent on good cause.

The notice periods specified in the managing director’s service agreement take precedence. The general provisions of the German Civil Code (Sections 611 et seq. BGB) apply supplementarily.

A Aufhebungsvereinbarung is a negotiated agreement between the company and the managing director to end both the corporate position and the service agreement — either immediately or on a specified future date — on mutually agreed terms, typically including a severance payment.

Continued salary payments, damages claims, severance obligations, and legal costs can all result from an improperly handled separation — often significantly exceeding the cost of proper legal advice from the outset.

As early as possible — ideally at the first stage of considering a separation. Early advice allows risks to be identified and a clear strategy developed before any steps are taken.

Schlun & Elseven Logo

Practice Group: German Corporate Law

Practice Group:
German Corporate Law

Jens Schmidt

German Corporate Lawyer

Martin Halfmann

German Corporate Lawyer

Julian Tillmann

German Corporate Lawyer

Viktor Malz, LL.M.

German Corporate Lawyer

Marija Boateng

German Corporate Lawyer

Dr. Simon Krämer
Dr. Simon Krämer, LL.M.

German Corporate Lawyer | Freelance

Contact Schlun & Elseven Rechtsanwälte

Please use our online form to outline your request to us. After receiving your request, we will make a brief initial assessment based on the facts described and provide you with a cost offer. You can then decide whether you would like to engage our services.

LIVE - Contact Form 001 ENGL
  • Your Case
  • Context
  • Your Details

Share your case with our attorneys


Locations & Office Times

Mo – Fr: 09:00 – 19:00
24h Contact: +49 221 93295960
Email: info@se-legal.de
Appointments made by prior reservation only.

Aachen Office

Schloss-Rahe-Straße 15
52072 Aachen
Tel: +49 241 4757140
Fax: 0241 47571469

Bayenthalgürtel 23
50968 Cologne
Tel: +49 221 93295960
Fax: 0221 932959669

Düsseldorfer Str. 70
40545 Düsseldorf
Tel: +49 211 171 8280
Fax: 0221 932959669

Locations & Office Times

Mo – Fr: 09:00 – 19:00
24h Contact: +49 221 93295960
Email: info@se-legal.de
Appointments by prior reservation only.

Conference Rooms

Berlin 10785, Potsdamer Platz 10

Frankfurt 60314, Hanauer Landstrasse 291 B

Hamburg 20354, Neuer Wall 63

München 80339, Theresienhöhe 28